Coal divestment

February 3, 2021

11:47 am

Do we need to get coal out of the energy system? Absolutely. When do we need to do it? As soon as possible. These two points are not in question. How we do it is more nuanced.
Let us first look at the numbers. Coal accounts for 40% of our global fossil CO2 emissions. Coal use rose in the mid-2000s, overtaking oil, which is now responsible for 34% of emissions. Coal emits nearly twice as much CO2 as gas, and two-thirds of coal emissions arise from electricity and heat generation.
This makes coal an obvious target for immediate replacement by renewables, in combination with gas. Investors have been divesting out of coal for some years now, and one might therefore assume it is rapidly falling out of favour. Unfortunately, this is not the case.
Coal demand has slowed, but there is no collapse, with China and emerging markets like India continuing to drive uptake. Global demand rose in seven out of the past ten years, including 2017 and 2018. Coal use fell by 1.7% in 2019, and was expected to fall 5% in 2020, less than the 9% drop expected in oil demand due to COVID-19 – but is projected to bounce with economic growth in 2021.
Does divestment work?
How can investors play their part in taking coal out of the energy mix? One approach is divestment, through selling shares and bonds of companies that generate revenue from coal. Both Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global (“GPFG”) and Sweden’s AP2 have taken this approach. GPFG divested from Anglo American last year, whilst AP2 sets strict criteria, with a 1% limit on turnover from coal. It has divested from 23 coal producing companies since 2013.
However, if a fund divests shares in a company that owns coal assets, those shares don’t disappear – another investor buys them. In effect, the capital is already in place, the existing assets are already funded. The investor who divested the assets did little to remove coal from the energy mix, or CO2 emissions from the atmosphere. They likely just passed on assets at an attractive price to a less ethically-minded investor.
Were Anglo American to stop mining coal in South Africa, and shut down their mines, they would lose their mining licence and the government would give the rights to another business. The net effect is shifting ownership, but it will not stop mining unless regulation or market signals dictate. The risk then is that divestment is a distraction from what needs to be done.
Cutting out coal requires a multi-pronged strategy
The focus of investors should be on giving a clear message to management and boards that they do not want to see capex deployed on developing coal assets. One successful example of this was the victory of the shareholders of Enea, a Polish energy company, stopping the construction of a new coal-fired power unit in 2019. Secondly, they can influence the banking sector, ensuring lenders don’t finance new coal assets. Thirdly, they can ensure that no companies in their portfolios have coal in their supply chain. The most obvious way to do this is to pressure companies not to buy coal-generated electricity.
Yet even with these actions, there is unlikely to be a global collapse in coal. For that to happen we would need to increase the cost of carbon emissions, via carbon pricing or a carbon tax. It is only with this regulatory pressure that companies will cease producing from existing coal mines, stranding existing coal assets and stopping new development. Auctions could also be used to retire coal-powered plants, following Germany’s lead.
It is likely that in the absence of global agreement, there will have to be a carbon border adjustment. The EU is currently considering such a mechanism. This will help end the offshoring of our developed market emissions to the developing world, and force decarbonisation in China. If effective carbon pricing and carbon taxes, introduced globally, were to happen in the next ten years, then divesting from coal-dependent companies now is likely the best strategy for an investor.
Divesting with care
One final point on sustainability. While we want to close coal mines as soon as possible, we must bear in mind the large numbers of workers and communities dependent on such mines. In South Africa, 92,000 people are directly employed in the coal industry, with potentially four to five times that number of jobs dependent on the industry. Meanwhile, Coal India, the national coal company, employs 270,000 workers. In the UK we have some understanding of clumsily closing coal mines and the societal impacts; since the 1980s the UK coal industry has shed over 250,000 jobs. These jobs were concentrated in areas such as South Wales. Decades after the job losses, we continue to see the social impacts through high unemployment, poor health and high rates of poverty in former coal mining regions. A divestment strategy, based on ethical considerations, must act to mitigate these acute social impacts, ensuing local communities are not overlooked in the goal to get coal assets off our hands.

The statements and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author as of the date of publication, and do not necessarily represent the view of RWC Partners Limited. This article does not constitute investment advice and the information shown above is for illustrative purposes only and should not be construed as a recommendation or advice to buy or sell any security. No investment strategy or risk management technique can guarantee returns or eliminate risks in any market environment

In case you missed it…

The term “RWC” may include any one or more RWC branded entities including RWC Partners Limited and RWC Asset Management LLP, each of which is authorised and regulated by the UK Financial Conduct Authority and, in the case of RWC Asset Management LLP, the US Securities and Exchange Commission; RWC Asset Advisors (US) LLC, which is registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission; and RWC Singapore (Pte) Limited, which is licensed as a Licensed Fund Management Company by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.

RWC may act as investment manager or adviser, or otherwise provide services, to more than one product pursuing a similar investment strategy or focus to the product detailed in this document. RWC seeks to minimise any conflicts of interest, and endeavours to act at all times in accordance with its legal and regulatory obligations as well as its own policies and codes of conduct.

This document is directed only at professional, institutional, wholesale or qualified investors. The services provided by RWC are available only to such persons. It is not intended for distribution to and should not be relied on by any person who would qualify as a retail or individual investor in any jurisdiction or for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction where such distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation.

This document has been prepared for general information purposes only and has not been delivered for registration in any jurisdiction nor has its content been reviewed or approved by any regulatory authority in any jurisdiction. The information contained herein does not constitute: (i) a binding legal agreement; (ii) legal, regulatory, tax, accounting or other advice; (iii) an offer, recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell shares in any fund, security, commodity, financial instrument or derivative linked to, or otherwise included in a portfolio managed or advised by RWC; or (iv) an offer to enter into any other transaction whatsoever (each a “Transaction”). No representations and/or warranties are made that the information contained herein is either up to date and/or accurate and is not intended to be used or relied upon by any counterparty, investor or any other third party.

RWC uses information from third party vendors, such as statistical and other data, that it believes to be reliable. However, the accuracy of this data, which may be used to calculate results or otherwise compile data that finds its way over time into RWC research data stored on its systems, is not guaranteed. If such information is not accurate, some of the conclusions reached or statements made may be adversely affected. RWC bears no responsibility for your investment research and/or investment decisions and you should consult your own lawyer, accountant, tax adviser or other professional adviser before entering into any Transaction. Any opinion expressed herein, which may be subjective in nature, may not be shared by all directors, officers, employees, or representatives of RWC and may be subject to change without notice. RWC is not liable for any decisions made or actions or inactions taken by you or others based on the contents of this document and neither RWC nor any of its directors, officers, employees, or representatives (including affiliates) accepts any liability whatsoever for any errors and/or omissions or for any direct, indirect, special, incidental, or consequential loss, damages, or expenses of any kind howsoever arising from the use of, or reliance on, any information contained herein.

Information contained in this document should not be viewed as indicative of future results. Past performance of any Transaction is not indicative of future results. The value of investments can go down as well as up. Certain assumptions and forward looking statements may have been made either for modelling purposes, to simplify the presentation and/or calculation of any projections or estimates contained herein and RWC does not represent that that any such assumptions or statements will reflect actual future events or that all assumptions have been considered or stated. Forward-looking statements are inherently uncertain, and changing factors such as those affecting the markets generally, or those affecting particular industries or issuers, may cause results to differ from those discussed. Accordingly, there can be no assurance that estimated returns or projections will be realised or that actual returns or performance results will not materially differ from those estimated herein. Some of the information contained in this document may be aggregated data of Transactions executed by RWC that has been compiled so as not to identify the underlying Transactions of any particular customer.

The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it has been given and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. In accepting receipt of the information transmitted you agree that you and/or your affiliates, partners, directors, officers and employees, as applicable, will keep all information strictly confidential. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information is prohibited. The information contained herein is confidential and is intended for the exclusive use of the intended recipient(s) to which this document has been provided. Any distribution or reproduction of this document is not authorised and is prohibited without the express written consent of RWC or any of its affiliates.

Changes in rates of exchange may cause the value of such investments to fluctuate. An investor may not be able to get back the amount invested and the loss on realisation may be very high and could result in a substantial or complete loss of the investment. In addition, an investor who realises their investment in a RWC-managed fund after a short period may not realise the amount originally invested as a result of charges made on the issue and/or redemption of such investment. The value of such interests for the purposes of purchases may differ from their value for the purpose of redemptions. No representations or warranties of any kind are intended or should be inferred with respect to the economic return from, or the tax consequences of, an investment in a RWC-managed fund. Current tax levels and reliefs may change. Depending on individual circumstances, this may affect investment returns. Nothing in this document constitutes advice on the merits of buying or selling a particular investment. This document expresses no views as to the suitability or appropriateness of the fund or any other investments described herein to the individual circumstances of any recipient.

AIFMD and Distribution in the European Economic Area (“EEA”)

The Alternative Fund Managers Directive (Directive 2011/61/EU) (“AIFMD”) is a regulatory regime which came into full effect in the EEA on 22 July 2014. RWC Asset Management LLP is an Alternative Investment Fund Manager (an “AIFM”) to certain funds managed by it (each an “AIF”). The AIFM is required to make available to investors certain prescribed information prior to their investment in an AIF. The majority of the prescribed information is contained in the latest Offering Document of the AIF. The remainder of the prescribed information is contained in the relevant AIF’s annual report and accounts. All of the information is provided in accordance with the AIFMD.

In relation to each member state of the EEA (each a “Member State”), this document may only be distributed and shares in a RWC fund (“Shares”) may only be offered and placed to the extent that (a) the relevant RWC fund is permitted to be marketed to professional investors in accordance with the AIFMD (as implemented into the local law/regulation of the relevant Member State); or (b) this document may otherwise be lawfully distributed and the Shares may lawfully offered or placed in that Member State (including at the initiative of the investor).

Information Required for Distribution of Foreign Collective Investment Schemes to Qualified Investors in Switzerland

The representative and paying agent of the RWC-managed funds in Switzerland (the “Representative in Switzerland”) FIRST INDEPENDENT FUND SERVICES LTD, Klausstrasse 33, CH-8008 Zurich. Swiss Paying Agent: Helvetische Bank AG, Seefeldstrasse 215, CH-8008 Zurich. In respect of the units of the RWC-managed funds distributed in Switzerland, the place of performance and jurisdiction is at the registered office of the Representative in Switzerland.

Ready to start talking?